Defectors from Magnamity of the unstoppable Icon and Hidden Thorns Treachery

[Prince of the Night]

what happens after a battles done to the soldiers who switched sides

They might still have problematic intimacys.

Debriefing and formal inductioin if suited Dismissal if not?

[TheCountAlucard]

what happens after a battles done to the soldiers who switched sides

They might still have problematic intimacys.

Isn’t that up to the players/ST to work out?

[nalak42]

Are you talk about soldiers who defected from to Thorns or from Thorns, also defected to Mask of Winters or from his side once the Mask was in charge?

[Prince of the Night]

Are you talk about soldiers who defected from to Thorns or from Thorns, also defected to Mask of Winters or from his side once the Mask was in charge?

From the charm Hidden Thorns Treachery

[JohnDoe244]

"Magnanimity of the Unstoppable Icon" is a Solar War Charm, page 421 of 3E Core. When your opponent rallies for numbers, some of their forces swap sides and join you.

"Hidden Thorn Treachery" is a Dragon-Blooded War Charm, page 282 of WFHW. Your spies have infiltrated enemy command and cause enemy troops to defect to your cause.

[TheCountAlucard]

Either way, there's no definitive answer to this. What you do with troops that have swapped sides should be something you decide at your table.

[habitableexoplanet]

Since Magnamity of the Unstoppable Icon is based on your personal charisma, if their Intimacies are relevant, I figure they would end up with a positive Intimacy towards you (probably Major) and maybe Intimacies against you and your side weakened.

I feel like Hidden Thorns Treachery would quite often end up with the defectors expecting to get paid, but one getting paid being happy to switch sides - in social terms more of a Bargain than an Instill.