Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

[V5] The Sabbat in V5

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #91
    Originally posted by Taggie View Post



    Gehenna was being fought, the destruction of the Camarilla and Anarchs was the necessary first step. until and unless that is achieved digging in the desert is pointless.
    Lol what? You're repeating in-game Sabbat leaders propaganda used by them to focus the bloodlust of young members of the sect not on them. There was no gehenna, those were turf wars on the continent scale, simple as that. When the real shit hit the fan, it was a true test of faith for Sabbat leaders. Some failed (stayed in NA, defected etc) some didn't and are now fulfilling the ultimate goal or at least try to fulfill.

    If you say whats happening in the world end of V20/V5 is not gehenna, it is crystal clear now you didn't read BJD.

    Comment


    • #92
      Originally posted by Val_Nir View Post
      Lol what? You're repeating in-game Sabbat leaders propaganda used by them to focus the bloodlust of young members of the sect not on them.
      actually, those leaders did believe in their own propaganda,
      it was specifically stated that, past the sectarian conflicts and the blood feuds, the elders sought to eliminate the methuselah protected by the Cam or at least cripple them by weakening/converting their pawns

      it wasn't a view shared by all, and was a point of contention between the elders and their divergent views on how to handle the ancients threat,

      the whole point of having a regent was to address that divergence,
      since the resources were limited, and the elders couldn't agree on how to handle things,
      the most powerful of them would take the decision (and would take the post of regent)

      if you check Mexico by Night, the candidates for regency were all devoted to the cause, but while one of them believed that the crusade on the cam was the way,
      the other two had their own different vision,
      neither of them were trying to "divert younger members of the sect",
      and whichever won the war for regency would decide if the sabbat should go maintain the war with the cam or...launch a space program or something

      man, I miss the good old days of Noddist elders bickering
      Last edited by Pleiades; 04-14-2020, 08:26 AM.


      -

      Comment


      • #93
        Originally posted by Pleiades View Post
        if you check Mexico by Night, the candidates for regency were all devoted to the cause, but while one of them believed that the crusade on the cam was the way,
        the other two had their own different vision,
        neither of them were trying to "divert younger members of the sect",
        and whichever won the war for regency would decide if the sabbat should go maintain the war with the cam or...launch a space program or something

        man, I miss the good old days of Noddist elders bickering
        To be fair, Melinda showed that at least one Regent was directly under the control of a near-Antediluvian because the Jyhad never been on sectarian lines. The Anarchs, Camarilla, and Sabbat are all just gamepieces fo the Ancients,.



        Author of Cthulhu Armageddon, I was a Teenage Weredeer, Straight Outta Fangton, Lucifer's Star, and the Supervillainy Saga.

        Forum Terms of Use
        the Contact Us link.

        Comment


        • #94
          Originally posted by CTPhipps View Post

          To be fair, Melinda showed that at least one Regent was directly under the control of a near-Antediluvian because the Jyhad never been on sectarian lines. The Anarchs, Camarilla, and Sabbat are all just gamepieces fo the Ancients,.
          this isn't a response to anything I said, is it?


          -

          Comment


          • #95
            Originally posted by Val_Nir View Post
            Lol what? You're repeating in-game Sabbat leaders propaganda used by them to focus the bloodlust of young members of the sect not on them. There was no gehenna, those were turf wars on the continent scale, simple as that. When the real shit hit the fan, it was a true test of faith for Sabbat leaders. Some failed (stayed in NA, defected etc) some didn't and are now fulfilling the ultimate goal or at least try to fulfill.

            If you say whats happening in the world end of V20/V5 is not gehenna, it is crystal clear now you didn't read BJD.

            End of VtM was Gehenna, it got retconned for Revised, after that we got some excuse plot to throw away the interesting parts of the setting to clear the way for the anarch focus of V5

            Comment


            • #96
              Originally posted by Pleiades View Post

              actually, those leaders did believe in their own propaganda,
              it was specifically stated that, past the sectarian conflicts and the blood feuds, the elders sought to eliminate the methuselah protected by the Cam or at least cripple them by weakening/converting their pawns

              it wasn't a view shared by all, and was a point of contention between the elders and their divergent views on how to handle the ancients threat,

              the whole point of having a regent was to address that divergence,
              since the resources were limited, and the elders couldn't agree on how to handle things,
              the most powerful of them would take the decision (and would take the post of regent)

              if you check Mexico by Night, the candidates for regency were all devoted to the cause, but while one of them believed that the crusade on the cam was the way,
              the other two had their own different vision,
              neither of them were trying to "divert younger members of the sect",
              and whichever won the war for regency would decide if the sabbat should go maintain the war with the cam or...launch a space program or something

              man, I miss the good old days of Noddist elders bickering
              If I did believe Sabbat elite to be all hypocrites to the last one, I wouldn't play Sabbat at all. My point was to remind that 1) braindead shovelheads and power-hungry Lasombra upstarts had to be directed at something while adults are conveying proper strategies - without a semblance of a real threat, the sect would quickly turn on itself - that's implied in virtually all Sabbat Revised-era books; 2) once the real threat appeared, once the Ancients, methuselahs and elders showed up as overtly as it's possible in WoD 21st century, there was no point in playing the whole contest game between hardcore and liberal parties of the sect. Engaging them indirectly (attacking Cam), undermining their power through crusades and sieges became pointless once the Puppetteers showed their ugly mugs in MENA themselves.

              I bet Polonia and other 'hawkish' Sabbat managed to win the masses over the 'rationale' Sabbat like Touraine, Vasantasena and Lucita, after all. Szechenyi Jolan was not even mentioned among Regency contesters in Beckett's Jyhad Diary, sadly.

              neither of them were trying to "divert younger members of the sect",
              You misunderstood my point. "Manipulating younger members of the sect" never exludes "genuinely believing the Ancients must be stopped". Some regent candidates are less into it, like Touraine or Jolan (Lucita, in BJD). Some, like Delmare, are very much into it.



              Comment


              • #97
                Originally posted by CTPhipps View Post

                To be fair, Melinda showed that at least one Regent was directly under the control of a near-Antediluvian because the Jyhad never been on sectarian lines. The Anarchs, Camarilla, and Sabbat are all just gamepieces fo the Ancients,.
                Of course they are. Nothing in the setting, however, forbids some semblance of hope of getting through their plots and schemes and forging your own path (or becoming another puppeteer yourself). That's the whole premise of WoD. "It's extremely easy to lose and extremely difficult to win. But not impossible."

                Comment


                • #98
                  Originally posted by Taggie View Post

                  End of VtM was Gehenna, it got retconned for Revised, after that we got some excuse plot to throw away the interesting parts of the setting to clear the way for the anarch focus of V5
                  Oh sure, Gehenna 2004, in which the Sabbat got either crushed, had to make peace with Camarilla, merge into a new sect, or got munched by Antes.
                  The movement of metaplot forward is a good thing, and as of now we know too little of what's exactly happening in gehenna war to say the sect been 'thrown away'. As I said already, you see a failure, I see an opportunity. Until any V5 book explicitly, literally says in huge letters specifically for those who love to misinterpret things, "SABBAT'S DEAD, BABY. SABBAT'S DEAD" all of our speculations are just speculations.
                  But of course, you do you.

                  Comment


                  • #99
                    Originally posted by Val_Nir View Post

                    Oh sure, Gehenna 2004, in which the Sabbat got either crushed, had to make peace with Camarilla, merge into a new sect, or got munched by Antes.
                    The movement of metaplot forward is a good thing, and as of now we know too little of what's exactly happening in gehenna war to say the sect been 'thrown away'. As I said already, you see a failure, I see an opportunity. Until any V5 book explicitly, literally says in huge letters specifically for those who love to misinterpret things, "SABBAT'S DEAD, BABY. SABBAT'S DEAD" all of our speculations are just speculations.
                    But of course, you do you.

                    The systems and themes of V5 so far give me very little hope, put it that way

                    Comment


                    • Originally posted by Taggie View Post


                      The systems and themes of V5 so far give me very little hope, put it that way

                      There are some possibilities and outcomes for Sabbat and other elements of the old VtM I liked which, if introduced in future books, would severely disappoint me and then I would join you in your grief. Until then, I'd rather keep some hope.
                      Cheers.

                      Comment


                      • Originally posted by Pleiades View Post

                        man, I miss the good old days of Noddist elders bickering
                        Me too.

                        By the way, Pleiades , whom would you love to see as Regent? and how would Sabbat go if we take BJD as starting point for new plot?

                        Comment


                        • On a related, but side note, where was it put out that Polonia went away to fight the Gehenna War? I can understand the assumption, but I also haven't seen that anywhere canon, but I admit I haven't read everything.

                          Comment


                          • Originally posted by Val_Nir View Post
                            Me too.

                            By the way, Pleiades , whom would you love to see as Regent? and how would Sabbat go if we take BJD as starting point for new plot?
                            I was more of a Jolan guy,
                            slow down the crusades, give more power to tzimisce (I actually hope v5 will have the sabbat ruled by the Tzim)

                            but now that she's been retconned (I think?)...I don't know, Lucita maybe?
                            I'd have to re-read BJD to give a definitive answer


                            -

                            Comment


                            • Originally posted by higgipedia View Post
                              On a related, but side note, where was it put out that Polonia went away to fight the Gehenna War? I can understand the assumption, but I also haven't seen that anywhere canon, but I admit I haven't read everything.

                              Polonia is it's main advocate in Beckett's Jyhad Diary. The whole Sabbat part of the book is about the new Regency. He's one of the main claimants and he presses the most hardcore Sabbat party line forward. Gehenna is here, Ancients are rising in Middle east, time for the final showdown. I'm kinda close to him on the whole thing, personally, although I'd rather wage it not so overtly and would prefer cainites like Jalan-Aajav at the helm of the war effort.

                              I strongly recommend BJD as an ultimate metaplot book which basically sets the stage for V5. Other than that, they did an oustanding effort in clearing up almost every major and minor storyline of the VtM metaplot since 1991. It's an amazing read.
                              Last edited by Val_Nir; 04-14-2020, 11:45 AM.

                              Comment


                              • Originally posted by Pleiades View Post

                                I was more of a Jolan guy,
                                slow down the crusades, give more power to tzimisce (I actually hope v5 will have the sabbat ruled by the Tzim)

                                but now that she's been retconned (I think?)...I don't know, Lucita maybe?
                                I'd have to re-read BJD to give a definitive answer

                                Y E S. I've always disliked Lasombra leadership. Not only it.

                                I never understood why the main 'darker' Vampire sect is dominated by Hispanic/Latin/Catholic references when the sect itself originated in Eastern Europe. I remain a stalwart supporter or either completely replacing Keepers with Fiends as Sabbat leaders, or at least making it an even thing.

                                In the same way, I'd be happy to see Hispanic/Latin/Catholic cultural references be balanced out with much, much more Slavic/Orthodox/Pagan flavor than what we had previously, and a switch of focus from temporal power (sieges, crusades, politics - Lasombra stuff) to spiritual (ideology, occult, research - Tzimisce).

                                Yes, there is not a mention of Jolan in the BJD, strangely. That's why I suppose her to be replaced with Lucita. I wish they bring the Mother of Horrors back.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X