Alright, third essay of the series. You probably know the drill by know.
Gonna post the first two parts together. They’re related and it makes sense to do so. The last one will come in a couple of days, just so I don’t drop a huge text on all of you.
As always, I hope you'll enjoy the reading but this is first of all fuel for discussion. Don't hesitate to tell me if you agree or disagree with something.
Heresy Rating: overall 4/5. Some parts are quite close to canon, but I throw out some rather wild theories and ideas here and there.
.
.
“You are of the Pantheon. You will be loved. You will be hated. You will be brilliant. Within two years you will be dead”
-The Wicked + The Divine
I’m a mythology geek. It goes back to my childhood: when I was a little kid the stories I asked for were monster ones and my parents answered to that with Odysseus, Hercules, Scylla and Charybdis. I added my passion for Egypt to that and pestered them for months until they found a book suitable for a kid that opened the way to Anubis, Set, Horus (my favorite trio). Growing up, I expanded that passion to other mythologies and nowadays it grew in such a big thing for me that I know bits from pretty much everywhere and will give a chance to anything related to myths.
The things I write often hide references to myths and play with them because it’s fun and something that makes me feel good. Again, mythology geek.
There’s a reason I love Scion and Beast.
“Come on Cinder, yet another element of Beast’s DNA you’re telling us you’ve loved for ages?”
Hey, I know it’s getting ridiculous, but it’s not my fault if it’s as if this game checked on the list of stuff I like and decided to go for most of it. It’s almost eerie at times.
All this serves as premise to my confession:
I never cared much about The Hero with a Thousand Faces
I know, I know. I read it, I recognize its merits and its importance, know what the deal with Campbell’s monomyth is...but I’m not a fan. Back in my teenage years (which was not that long ago but crap I’m suddenly 27 and feel so old), I used to actively oppose it with the aid of the iconoclastic passion that comes with being a teen. Even nowadays I try to ignore it’s a thing. Not sure how much is me not actually liking what Joseph Campbell wrote and how much is me being afraid he might be right and not wanting to know how the rules behind the magic are, but that’s how it is.
It’s weird, because those elements that Campbell started from when he came up with his theories? Love them. Stuff like mythical recurrence, subconscious symbolism, archetypes hidden within the human mind that might have a higher meaning? Common narratives found across different cultures? Patchworks made with the common themes of different myths? The kind of stuff Jung had fun with when he wanted to piss Freud off? I’m 100% into that. I can rant about that for hours (and I’m kinda already doing so here)
It’s about what Campbell built upon from that I honestly can’t be bothered to think much about.
This just for saying that, yes, this analysis will talk about the monomyth as Beast envisions it among other things, but it’s gonna be less reverential towards The Hero with a Thousand Faces than one might reasonably expect.
Alright, time for the Mythology essay. Enjoy the ride.
Gonna post the first two parts together. They’re related and it makes sense to do so. The last one will come in a couple of days, just so I don’t drop a huge text on all of you.
As always, I hope you'll enjoy the reading but this is first of all fuel for discussion. Don't hesitate to tell me if you agree or disagree with something.
Heresy Rating: overall 4/5. Some parts are quite close to canon, but I throw out some rather wild theories and ideas here and there.
.
.
Mythology, the Monomyth and Mythic Recurrence
“You are of the Pantheon. You will be loved. You will be hated. You will be brilliant. Within two years you will be dead”
-The Wicked + The Divine
I’m a mythology geek. It goes back to my childhood: when I was a little kid the stories I asked for were monster ones and my parents answered to that with Odysseus, Hercules, Scylla and Charybdis. I added my passion for Egypt to that and pestered them for months until they found a book suitable for a kid that opened the way to Anubis, Set, Horus (my favorite trio). Growing up, I expanded that passion to other mythologies and nowadays it grew in such a big thing for me that I know bits from pretty much everywhere and will give a chance to anything related to myths.
The things I write often hide references to myths and play with them because it’s fun and something that makes me feel good. Again, mythology geek.
There’s a reason I love Scion and Beast.
“Come on Cinder, yet another element of Beast’s DNA you’re telling us you’ve loved for ages?”
Hey, I know it’s getting ridiculous, but it’s not my fault if it’s as if this game checked on the list of stuff I like and decided to go for most of it. It’s almost eerie at times.
All this serves as premise to my confession:
I never cared much about The Hero with a Thousand Faces
I know, I know. I read it, I recognize its merits and its importance, know what the deal with Campbell’s monomyth is...but I’m not a fan. Back in my teenage years (which was not that long ago but crap I’m suddenly 27 and feel so old), I used to actively oppose it with the aid of the iconoclastic passion that comes with being a teen. Even nowadays I try to ignore it’s a thing. Not sure how much is me not actually liking what Joseph Campbell wrote and how much is me being afraid he might be right and not wanting to know how the rules behind the magic are, but that’s how it is.
It’s weird, because those elements that Campbell started from when he came up with his theories? Love them. Stuff like mythical recurrence, subconscious symbolism, archetypes hidden within the human mind that might have a higher meaning? Common narratives found across different cultures? Patchworks made with the common themes of different myths? The kind of stuff Jung had fun with when he wanted to piss Freud off? I’m 100% into that. I can rant about that for hours (and I’m kinda already doing so here)
It’s about what Campbell built upon from that I honestly can’t be bothered to think much about.
This just for saying that, yes, this analysis will talk about the monomyth as Beast envisions it among other things, but it’s gonna be less reverential towards The Hero with a Thousand Faces than one might reasonably expect.
Alright, time for the Mythology essay. Enjoy the ride.
Comment