Originally posted by Necrophear
View Post
When you said that, it was in reference to the default beliefs of the printed line. Further, Luna and the Firstborn are even recognized in wyrdhampster's post as being extant.
Tell me how North American exceptionalism and society wouldn't influence burgeoning cultures, and then refute the simple fact that Werewolf society is dependent upon human society both mechanically and narratively. Politics didn't influence the Sundering, matters politick did influence how the Sundering is approached, interpreted, and passed down as is the simple truth of oral traditions - yes, even those with talespinners who lived the experience, and especially in a fictional setting where the old are invariably unreliable narrators.
Most real-world mythologies have a Great Flood or Cinderella story, but the context in which these stories are told and the intended morals are as diverse as the cultures that tell them. Just because there need to be some key similarities representing ineffable events doesn't mean that the interpretations of these events have to be the same.
As for the setting, backtracking doesn't become you. The context given for the core game and most of its supplements are North American and North American views (or stereotypes of the same), you already agreed to that. I've already covered ties specifically to North American native tribes, and you yourself brought up one or two conceits based on the modern United States.
Mechanically, that means little outside the core book, but narratively it carries the implication of bias in what tales to tell and how to tell them.
Mechanically, that means little outside the core book, but narratively it carries the implication of bias in what tales to tell and how to tell them.
Within the core book, especially in second edition, the printed material speaks against what we're told about werewolf culture in supplements, leaving us with two options. First, that Luna is universal, and as such it makes sense that you ignore supplemental material. Second, that the core book doesn't wish to overwhelm new players with the nuance of a million cultures and subcultures, none of which can be adequately covered in a book to completion.
It is the second option that I subscribe to, and allow additional texts to supplement the world alongside any necessary homebrew.
It is the second option that I subscribe to, and allow additional texts to supplement the world alongside any necessary homebrew.
Comment